About The Nantucket Lobster Trap
The Nantucket Lobster Trap is an iconic island dining spot that brings the classic flavors of coastal New England to your plate. Known for its fresh seafood, expertly prepared lobster, and diverse menu options, this restaurant is a favorite for both locals and visitors. Whether you’re craving a hearty clambake, a perfectly stuffed lobster, or a non-seafood entrée, there’s something for everyone at this welcoming eatery.
Menu Highlights
Starters
- Steamers & Steamed Mussels: Fresh and flavorful, served with butter for dipping.
- Clams Casino: Baked with seasoned breadcrumbs for a savory start.
- Quahog Chowder: Available by the cup or bowl, a Nantucket staple.
- Stuffed Shrimp: Shrimp wrapped in bacon and packed with flavor.
Raw Bar
- Shrimp Cocktail: Perfectly chilled and served with tangy cocktail sauce.
- Littlenecks & Oysters: Freshly shucked and served on the half shell.
Salads
- Caesar Salad: Add chicken, shrimp, or lobster salad for a hearty twist.
- House Salad: Fresh greens with your choice of dressing.
Rolls
- New England Style: Chilled lobster claw and knuckle meat with light mayo and celery, served on a brioche bun.
- Connecticut Style: Warm lobster meat smothered in herbed butter.
- Nantucket Bay Scallop Roll: Lightly breaded scallops with house aioli.
Entrées
- Lobster: Served boiled, baked, or stuffed with your choice of two sides.
- New England Clambake: Boiled lobster with steamers, mussels, corn on the cob, and red potatoes in drawn butter.
- Seafood Combination: A variety of seafood favorites, including lobster, scallops, and fried fish.
Pasta
- Bay Scallop Bucatini: Nantucket Bay scallops with pancetta, garlic, and spinach in a white wine sauce.
- Bouillabaisse: French-inspired seafood stew with shellfish and fresh fish.
Non-Seafood Offerings
- Trap Burger: Certified Angus beef with lettuce, tomato, and onion, served on a brioche bun. Add cheese or bacon for extra indulgence.
- Teriyaki Steak: Served with grilled asparagus and white rice.
- Curried Chicken: A Caribbean-style dish paired with coconut rice.
Sides
- Coleslaw, French Fries, Corn on the Cob, Red Bliss Potatoes, Sweet Potato Fries, Coconut White Rice, or Seafood Stuffing.
Why Choose The Nantucket Lobster Trap?
- Fresh, Local Ingredients: Featuring Nantucket’s finest seafood.
- Authentic Dining Experience: Perfect for casual gatherings or special celebrations.
- Wide Variety: Seafood classics and non-seafood options to suit every palate.
Insider Tip
Don’t miss the New England Clambake for a full coastal dining experience, and pair your meal with a local craft beer for the perfect Nantucket vibe.
The Nantucket Lobster Trap offers an authentic taste of the island’s rich maritime tradition. It’s a must-visit for any seafood lover or anyone looking to enjoy a true Nantucket dining experience.
About Sayle’s Seafood
Sayle’s Seafood is a Nantucket institution known for its high-quality, fresh-off-the-boat seafood. Offering both takeout and catering options, it’s the perfect spot for indulging in classic New England seafood dishes. Whether you’re craving a lobster dinner, fried seafood platters, or a casual sandwich, Sayle’s delivers flavors that epitomize coastal comfort.
Menu Highlights
Seafood Appetizers
- Sayle’s Nantucket Clam Chowder: Creamy, hearty, and filled with fresh clams.
- Fried Scallops: Served with lemon and tartar sauce for the ultimate coastal bite.
- Steamer & Mussel Combo: Half a pound of each with butter for dipping.
Fish Sandwiches
(All sandwiches are served with potato chips and coleslaw):
- Lobster Salad Roll (1/3 lb.): Sweet, buttery lobster on a toasted roll.
- Fried Clam Roll: Crispy clams paired with tangy tartar sauce.
- Tuna Steak Sandwich: A hearty option for seafood lovers.
Seafood Dinners
(Served with fries, coleslaw, and clam chowder):
- Fried Seafood Platter: A combination of fried fish, clams, shrimp, and scallops.
- Fried Bay Scallops: Sweet and tender Nantucket scallops.
- Baked Halibut: A healthier take on a seafood classic, served with sides.
Clambake Dinner #1
- 1 ¼ lb. Lobster, Clams, Mussels, and Corn: Paired with clam chowder, red potatoes, and melted butter.
Raw Bar
- Little Neck Clams on the Half Shell
- Wellfleet Oysters
- Pocomo Meadow Oysters
Non-Seafood Options
- Chicken Fingers: Served with a choice of BBQ, honey mustard, or sweet & sour.
- Mozzarella Sticks: Crispy on the outside, gooey on the inside.
Side Orders
- Cape Cod Potato Chips, Corn on the Cob, or Red Potatoes
- Coleslaw (4 oz)
Why Choose Sayle’s Seafood?
- Freshness Guaranteed: Seafood sourced directly from Nantucket’s waters.
- Takeout Convenience: Enjoy restaurant-quality seafood at home or on the beach.
- Variety for All: From fried platters to baked dinners and raw bar selections, there’s something for every seafood enthusiast.
Insider Tip
For a quintessential New England experience, order the Clambake Dinner and enjoy it at one of Nantucket’s beautiful beaches. Pair it with a side of clam chowder for an unbeatable meal!
Sayle’s Seafood offers a true taste of Nantucket’s maritime heritage. Whether you’re a local or just visiting, this is a must-try destination for fresh and flavorful seafood.
About Casa Real
Casa Real Restaurant & Bar delivers a vibrant blend of authentic Mexican and Salvadoran cuisines in the heart of Nantucket. Known for its lively atmosphere, colorful cocktails, and diverse menu, it’s the go-to spot for those craving bold flavors and a festive dining experience. Whether you’re gathering with friends or enjoying a casual family meal, Casa Real offers something for everyone.
Menu Highlights
Appetizers
- Pupusas: Traditional Salvadoran corn or rice tortillas filled with cheese, beans, or loroco.
- Fried Yuca with Chicharrón: Served with tangy pickled cabbage slaw.
- Ceviche: Fresh shrimp or fish marinated in lime juice with tomatoes and onions.
Fajitas
All fajitas are served with grilled onions and peppers, a side of beans, rice, and fresh salad:
- Chicken Fajitas
- Steak Fajitas
- Super Combo Fajitas: Chicken, steak, and shrimp.
Mexican Specialties
- Tacos: Available with steak, chicken, or grilled shrimp, served with cilantro, onions, and salsa.
- Torta: A traditional Mexican sandwich with your choice of meat, fresh avocado, refried beans, and jalapeños.
- Molcajete: A sizzling stone bowl filled with grilled steak, chicken, shrimp, and vegetables.
Seafood
- Fried Mojarra: Whole fried fish served with rice, salad, and tortillas.
- Shrimp Scampi: Sautéed shrimp in a garlic butter sauce over linguini.
Breakfast
- Huevo Rancheros: Two eggs served over corn tortillas, topped with ranchero sauce and fresh vegetables.
- Tipico Centroamericano: A traditional plate featuring fried eggs, plantains, and beans.
Desserts
- Churros: A classic Mexican pastry dusted with cinnamon sugar.
- Flan: Creamy caramel custard topped with whipped cream.
Drinks
- House Margaritas: Available in classic, jalapeño, or flavored varieties.
- Micheladas: Mexican-style Bloody Mary with beer.
- Non-Alcoholic: Horchata, Jarritos, and soft drinks.
Why Choose Casa Real?
- Authentic Cuisine: Experience bold and traditional flavors from Mexico and El Salvador.
- Lively Atmosphere: Perfect for celebrations, family dinners, or casual gatherings.
- Extensive Menu: From breakfast to late-night drinks, they have it all.
Insider Tip
Don’t miss their house-made pupusas and classic margaritas. Pair them for an unforgettable meal!
Casa Real is conveniently located at 5 Macy’s Lane, making it a favorite spot for locals and visitors alike. Stop by to enjoy their festive dining experience!
About Nantucket Meat & Fish Market
Nestled within the heart of the bustling Nantucket Meat & Fish Market, this counter is your one-stop shop for a quick and satisfying meal alongside a full grocery experience. Known for its freshly made bagels, Starbucks coffee service, and assortment of grab-and-go breakfast and lunch items, the market also provides an impressive selection of beer, wine, pre-prepped meats, fish, and vegetables.
Menu Highlights
Breakfast Sandwiches:
- Egg & Cheese: The classic combination to start your day.
- Bacon Egg Cheese: Add crispy bacon to your morning routine.
- Bagel & Lox: Cream cheese and fresh lox layered on a toasted bagel.
Lunch Sandwiches:
- Turkey Club: A hearty combination of turkey, bacon, lettuce, and tomato.
- Lobster Roll: Fresh lobster meat, lightly dressed, served on a toasted roll.
- Veggie Wrap: Packed with fresh vegetables and perfect for a lighter option.
Soups:
- Clam Chowder: Creamy, flavorful, and loaded with tender clams.
- Lobster Bisque: A rich and indulgent soup, perfect for any occasion.
Café & Deli:
- Full Starbucks café serving a wide range of beverages.
- Scratch-made pastries and freshly prepared bagels daily.
- A prepared foods case filled with ready-to-eat options.
More Than Just a Counter
The market extends beyond its counter offerings with a wide variety of beer and wine, along with expertly curated grocery items. Whether you’re looking for fresh seafood, perfectly prepped cuts of meat, or seasonal vegetables, Nantucket Meat & Fish Market has you covered.
Why Choose Nantucket Meat & Fish Market?
- Convenience: A quick-service counter for meals, plus all your grocery and beverage needs in one location.
- Premium Quality: All items are freshly prepared and made with high-quality ingredients.
- Full-Service Experience: Enjoy breakfast or lunch, pick up a bottle of wine, and stock up on premium groceries all in one stop.
Getting There
Centrally located and easily accessible, Nantucket Meat & Fish Market Counter makes it simple to grab a meal or stock up on essentials. Parking is available for your convenience.
Insider Tip:
Start your morning with a Bagel & Lox and a Starbucks latte, then swing back later for their famous Lobster Roll paired with a bottle of locally sourced wine for the ultimate Nantucket picnic.
About Straight Wharf Fish
Straight Wharf Fish offers an authentic coastal New England dining experience, blending the freshest local seafood with a creative, contemporary twist. Located right by the water, it provides a laid-back yet refined atmosphere that perfectly encapsulates Nantucket’s charm. Ideal for casual lunches or evening gatherings, it’s a go-to destination for seafood lovers.
Menu Highlights
Some Things:
- Bluefish Pâté: Served with pickles and crackers, a savory start to your meal.
- Steamers & Frites: Steamed New England clams accompanied by crispy fries.
- Clam Chowder: A hearty bowl of smoked bacon, potatoes, and oyster crackers; available in small, large, or quart sizes.
Boat People:
- Caviar Sandwich: A decadent combination of king’s Hawaiian bread, parmesan, red pepper jelly, and funyun.
- Onion Rings: Perfectly hand-cut and paired with a zesty aïoli dipping sauce.
Boxes (served with lemon and tartar sauce):
- Whole Belly Clams: Golden fried to perfection.
- Scallops: Sweet and tender, an island favorite.
- Fish: Classic fried fish for a comforting, flavorful bite.
Rolls & Sandwiches:
- Lobster Roll: Stuffed with buttery lobster meat, chilled and served on a toasted bun.
- The Walter: Grilled swordfish on a bun with tartar sauce and lemon.
- Smash Burger: Prime chuck patty, American cheese, and special sauce for a hearty alternative to seafood.
Sides & Sweets:
- Cornbread with Maple-Aleppo Butter: Sweet, savory, and perfectly spiced.
- It’s Giving Key Lime Pie: A refreshing citrusy dessert with Ritz cracker crust and whipped cream.
Why Choose Straight Wharf Fish?
- Authentic New England Cuisine: Fresh, locally sourced seafood with innovative presentations.
- Casual Waterfront Atmosphere: Relax with views of the harbor while enjoying expertly crafted dishes.
- Something for Everyone: From seafood classics to creative sandwiches, the menu offers variety.
Getting There
Straight Wharf Fish is conveniently located by the waterfront, making it an ideal dining destination whether you’re exploring downtown Nantucket or docking from a boat ride. Parking and bike racks are available nearby.
Insider Tip:
Try the Caviar Sandwich for a truly indulgent experience or the Steamers & Frites for a classic New England treat. Pair your meal with a refreshing glass of white wine for the perfect seaside dining experience.
About Bartlett’s Farm
On Nantucket’s windswept south shore, among scrub pines and rare sandplains, time stands still in the heirloom fields of Bartlett’s Ocean View Farm. Established in 1843, the fields have been lovingly tended by the Bartlett family for generations. Today, Bartlett’s Farm has grown into one of New England’s most celebrated family-owned farms, offering a holistic blend of bucolic charm and exceptional service.
In addition to being a cherished local grocery store and garden center, Bartlett’s is a hub for fresh, organically grown produce, top-notch prepared foods, and specialty sandwiches made fresh daily. Whether you’re stocking up for a beach picnic or grabbing a quick lunch, Bartlett’s Farm combines convenience with farm-to-table excellence.
Menu Highlights
Specialty Sandwiches:
- The Islander: Authentic jerk chicken with cheddar cheese, coleslaw, and cilantro pineapple dressing on ciabatta.
- Cisco Caprese: Fresh mozzarella, basil pesto, balsamic glaze, farm tomatoes, and greens (seasonal).
- Tom Nevers Turkey Club: Oven-roasted turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo, and avocado spread on your choice of bread.
- Great Point Cuban: Pulled pork with beechwood ham, yellow mustard, Swiss cheese, and dill pickles on a Cuban roll.
Comfort Classics:
- Bartlett’s BLT: Crispy bacon, mayo, lettuce, and farm-fresh tomatoes (seasonal).
- Grilled Cheese with Bacon: Melted cheddar and American cheese with crispy bacon on your choice of bread.
- Reuben: Corned beef, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and Russian dressing on marble rye.
Bakery Favorites:
- Cookies: Classic options like chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, and shortbread pecan.
- Seasonal Pastries: Rotating selection of muffins, scones, and breads baked fresh daily.
Beyond the Farmstand
Bartlett’s Farm is more than just a destination for delicious food. It’s a full-service grocery store stocked with local and gourmet products, a garden center brimming with plants and flowers, and a market offering pre-prepped meats, fresh seafood, and seasonal vegetables. With an extensive selection of beer and wine, you can complete your shopping while enjoying the farm’s unique charm.
Why Visit Bartlett’s Farm?
- Farm-to-Table Freshness: Ingredients sourced directly from the farm’s fields and greenhouses.
- Local Charm: A Nantucket institution blending history and modern convenience.
- One-Stop Shop: Grocery essentials, prepared foods, and unique finds all in one place.
Getting There
Located just a short drive or bike ride from Nantucket Town, Bartlett’s Farm is easily accessible with ample parking and bike racks. Its scenic location makes it a must-visit for locals and visitors alike.
Insider Tip
Don’t leave without trying The Rachel, a specialty sandwich featuring sliced turkey, farm-made coleslaw, melted Swiss cheese, and Russian dressing on toasted Italian bread. Pair it with a farm-fresh cookie for a satisfying meal that embodies the heart of Bartlett’s Farm.
About Claudette’s Sandwich Shop
Claudette’s Sandwich Shop is a cozy, locally loved eatery known for its freshly prepared sandwiches and breakfast options. Located just a short walk from the beach, it’s a popular spot for a quick, satisfying meal any time of the day.
Menu Highlights
Signature Sandwiches:
All sandwiches are made with whole wheat bread and come with lettuce and the signature House Sauce—a zesty blend of mayo, spicy brown mustard, and horseradish. Add “The Works” (cheddar cheese, tomatoes, red onion, shredded carrots, and cucumber) at no extra cost.
- Smoked Turkey
- Ham and Cheese
- Veggie
- Meatloaf
- Turkey Salad
Breakfast Options:
Served daily from 8:00 AM to 11:00 AM:
- Breakfast Sandwiches: Sausage, egg, and cheese; ham, egg, and cheese; or bacon, egg, and cheese on an English muffin or bagel.
Why Choose Claudette’s Sandwich Shop?
- Fresh Ingredients: All sandwiches are made to order with high-quality, fresh ingredients.
- Beachside Convenience: Perfect for grabbing a meal on the way to or from the beach.
- Customization: Substitute the House Sauce for mayo or mustard, and enjoy gluten-free bread options.
Getting There
Claudette’s is conveniently located near the beach and offers easy access by foot or bike. Limited parking is available for those driving.
Insider Tip:
Try the Smoked Turkey Sandwich with “The Works” for a delicious, fully loaded lunch. Breakfast fans will love the hearty Bacon, Egg, and Cheese sandwich to kick-start their day!
About Steamboat Pizza
Steamboat Pizza is a go-to spot on Nantucket for delicious, authentic New York-style pizza. Offering options by the slice or whole pies, this pizzeria is perfect for a quick bite or a casual meal with friends and family. Known for its quality ingredients and friendly service, Steamboat Pizza is a local favorite.
Menu Highlights
Pizza Options:
- By the Slice: Enjoy a single slice of their classic cheese pizza or customize with toppings.
- Classic 18” Cheese Pizza: A large pie perfect for sharing.
- Daily Special: Two slices of cheese pizza at a great value.
Toppings:
- Traditional: Pepperoni, Sausage, Mushrooms, Black Olives, Green Peppers.
- Specialty: Buffalo Chicken, Roasted Garlic, Artichoke Hearts, Pineapple.
Sides and Beverages:
- Caesar Salad: A crisp, fresh complement to your pizza.
- Drinks: Soft drinks like Coke, Diet Coke, and root beer.
Why Choose Steamboat Pizza?
- Quality Ingredients: Fresh toppings and dough made daily.
- Casual Dining: Perfect for an easy, laid-back meal.
- Family-Friendly: A menu that appeals to both kids and adults.
Getting There
Steamboat Pizza is centrally located on Nantucket, making it an easy stop during your day. Parking is available nearby for added convenience.
Insider Tip:
Order the Classic 18” Cheese Pizza and customize it with your favorite toppings for a truly satisfying meal. Don’t forget to pair it with a Caesar Salad for a complete dining experience!
About Millie’s Mid-Island
Millie’s Mid-Island offers the same great flavors as its beloved beachside counterpart but in a central location for convenience. Known for its fresh, coastal-inspired dishes, this spot is perfect for those craving hearty tacos, flavorful quesadillas, and satisfying salads.
Menu Highlights
Popular Items:
- Tuckernuck Tacos: Grilled chicken, roasted poblano peppers, guacamole, and pico de gallo.
- Street Corn Beach Bowl: Smoky grilled corn, black beans, romaine, and cotija cheese topped with chipotle crema.
- Rhode Island Quesadilla: Grilled marinated steak with Monterey Jack cheese and caramelized onions.
Salads and Bowls:
- Wauwinet Salad: Grilled shrimp, mixed greens, grape tomatoes, and a citrus vinaigrette.
- Great Point Bowl: Mango, crushed peanuts, summer greens, and blackened chicken.
Why Choose Millie’s Mid-Island?
- Convenience: A central location offering the same fresh menu items as the original Millie’s.
- Coastal Flavors: Signature dishes inspired by New England and Baja cuisine.
- Family-Friendly: Options for everyone, including kids’ meals and shareable plates.
Getting There
Millie’s Mid-Island is located in a convenient spot, accessible by car or bike, with plenty of parking available nearby.
Insider Tip:
Pair the Westender Taco with a side of Guacamole and Chips for a filling and flavorful meal. The Wauwinet Salad is a refreshing option for lighter fare!
About Henry Jr. Sandwich Shop
Henry Jr. Sandwich Shop is a quintessential deli located on Orange Street, offering freshly made sandwiches, salads, and more. Whether you’re looking for a quick lunch, a grab-and-go option, or a casual meal, this sandwich shop is known for its friendly service and satisfying portions.
Menu Highlights
Featured Sandwiches:
- Italian Grinder: Ham, salami, and provolone cheese for a classic deli flavor.
- Roast Beef with Herbs and Garlic: Roast beef paired with a savory herb and garlic cream cheese spread.
- Meatball Sub: Classic meatballs smothered in marinara sauce and melted cheese.
Salads:
- Greek Salad: Lettuce, tomato, feta, olives, cucumbers, and Greek dressing.
- Caesar Salad: Fresh romaine, croutons, parmesan, and Caesar dressing.
Beverages:
- Soft Drinks: Options like Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, and Ginger Ale.
- Juices: Including iced tea, lemonade, and orange mango.
Why Choose Henry Jr. Sandwich Shop?
- Classic Deli Experience: A menu filled with traditional deli favorites prepared fresh daily.
- Great Value: Generous portions at reasonable prices.
- Convenient Location: Located on Orange Street, just minutes from downtown Nantucket.
Getting There
Henry Jr. Sandwich Shop is easily accessible by car or bike, with parking available nearby. Its location on Orange Street makes it a convenient stop for both locals and visitors.
Insider Tip:
Try the Italian Grinder for a hearty, flavorful sandwich or the Greek Salad for a lighter option. Pair your meal with a refreshing lemonade for the perfect combo!
