About Straight Wharf Fish
Straight Wharf Fish offers an authentic coastal New England dining experience, blending the freshest local seafood with a creative, contemporary twist. Located right by the water, it provides a laid-back yet refined atmosphere that perfectly encapsulates Nantucket’s charm. Ideal for casual lunches or evening gatherings, it’s a go-to destination for seafood lovers.
Menu Highlights
Some Things:
- Bluefish Pâté: Served with pickles and crackers, a savory start to your meal.
- Steamers & Frites: Steamed New England clams accompanied by crispy fries.
- Clam Chowder: A hearty bowl of smoked bacon, potatoes, and oyster crackers; available in small, large, or quart sizes.
Boat People:
- Caviar Sandwich: A decadent combination of king’s Hawaiian bread, parmesan, red pepper jelly, and funyun.
- Onion Rings: Perfectly hand-cut and paired with a zesty aïoli dipping sauce.
Boxes (served with lemon and tartar sauce):
- Whole Belly Clams: Golden fried to perfection.
- Scallops: Sweet and tender, an island favorite.
- Fish: Classic fried fish for a comforting, flavorful bite.
Rolls & Sandwiches:
- Lobster Roll: Stuffed with buttery lobster meat, chilled and served on a toasted bun.
- The Walter: Grilled swordfish on a bun with tartar sauce and lemon.
- Smash Burger: Prime chuck patty, American cheese, and special sauce for a hearty alternative to seafood.
Sides & Sweets:
- Cornbread with Maple-Aleppo Butter: Sweet, savory, and perfectly spiced.
- It’s Giving Key Lime Pie: A refreshing citrusy dessert with Ritz cracker crust and whipped cream.
Why Choose Straight Wharf Fish?
- Authentic New England Cuisine: Fresh, locally sourced seafood with innovative presentations.
- Casual Waterfront Atmosphere: Relax with views of the harbor while enjoying expertly crafted dishes.
- Something for Everyone: From seafood classics to creative sandwiches, the menu offers variety.
Getting There
Straight Wharf Fish is conveniently located by the waterfront, making it an ideal dining destination whether you’re exploring downtown Nantucket or docking from a boat ride. Parking and bike racks are available nearby.
Insider Tip:
Try the Caviar Sandwich for a truly indulgent experience or the Steamers & Frites for a classic New England treat. Pair your meal with a refreshing glass of white wine for the perfect seaside dining experience.
About Lemon Press
Lemon Press is a bright and welcoming café specializing in health-focused, globally inspired cuisine. Known for its locally sourced ingredients and innovative menu, Lemon Press offers something for everyone, from hearty breakfast options to refreshing juices and vibrant salads.
Menu Highlights
Drinks:
- Grey Lady Latte: Lavender-infused espresso with a touch of vanilla.
- Healing Latte: A mix of butterfly pea, chamomile, and lavender with maple for a soothing experience.
- Detox Latte: Activated charcoal, vanilla, and espresso for a bold and detoxifying boost.
Health-Focused Offerings:
Lemon Press serves breakfast sandwiches, globally inspired bowls, wraps, fresh juices, and smoothies. Their cold-pressed juices and superfood smoothies are perfect for fueling your Nantucket adventures.
Why Choose Lemon Press?
- Innovative Menu: A focus on fresh, health-conscious ingredients and bold flavors.
- Vibrant Atmosphere: Enjoy a cheerful and stylish space perfect for dining in or grabbing a meal to go.
- Sustainably Sourced: Committed to supporting local farmers and using eco-friendly practices.
Getting There
Lemon Press is located in the heart of Nantucket, making it a convenient stop for breakfast, lunch, or a refreshing beverage. Parking and bike racks are available nearby.
Insider Tip:
Try the Persian Breakfast or one of their refreshing smoothies for a nourishing start to your day. Pair it with a juice shot for an extra health boost!
About The Gaslight
Opened in June 2019, The Gaslight is a premier dining and live music venue in downtown Nantucket. Co-owned by Chef Liam Mackey, Mixologist Clinton Terry, and Sommelier Stephen Bowler, the establishment offers a Japanese Izakaya-inspired menu featuring haute street food-style pan-Asian cuisine. The open-concept bar and restaurant provide a lively atmosphere, complemented by live music performances from local and regional artists.
Dining Highlights
- Signature Dishes:
- Hamachi Ceviche: Fresh hamachi prepared with a Japanese twist.
- Japanese Short Ribs: Tender short ribs with authentic flavors.
- Cheeseburger Bao Buns: A fusion of classic American and Asian cuisines.
- Beverage Selection: The bar program features innovative, fresh ingredient-forward cocktails with culinary-inspired themes, rotating craft beers on tap, and a wine list focusing on fun, funky, natural selections. Notably, The Gaslight houses Nantucket’s only Champagne vending machine, courtesy of Moët.
- Ambiance: The Gaslight boasts a vibrant and energetic atmosphere, with live music starting around 10:30 PM during the summer. The venue features both indoor and outdoor seating, including a patio area, making it a popular spot for both dining and entertainment.
Why Choose The Gaslight?
- Innovative Cuisine: Experience a unique blend of Japanese Izakaya-inspired dishes crafted with local ingredients.
- Live Entertainment: Enjoy performances by talented musicians, enhancing your dining experience.
- Creative Beverages: Savor inventive cocktails and a curated selection of wines and beers.
Getting There
Located at 3 North Union Street, The Gaslight is easily accessible from downtown Nantucket. Street parking is available, though it may be limited during peak hours.
Insider Tip:
Reservations are recommended, especially during peak seasons. For a unique experience, visit during the late-night hours to enjoy live music alongside your meal.
About The Nautilus
Established in 2014, The Nautilus is a cornerstone of Nantucket’s dining scene, offering a unique blend of New England coastal cuisine with Asian and global street food influences. Owned and operated by a trio of culinary entrepreneurs—Executive Chef Liam Mackey, Mixologist Clinton Terry, and Sommelier Stephen Bowler—the restaurant emphasizes a shared social dining experience in a lively atmosphere.
Dining Highlights
- Signature Dishes:
- Blue Crab Fried Rice: A flavorful dish featuring fresh blue crab and aromatic rice.
- Pork Belly Buns: Steamed buns filled with tender pork belly and complemented by house-made sauces.
- Japanese Hamachi Crudo: Fresh hamachi served with creative accompaniments.
- Beverage Selection: The Nautilus boasts an extensive selection of wines, sakes, and innovative cocktails crafted with seasonal and regional inspirations.
- Ambiance: With less than 50 seats, The Nautilus offers an intimate yet energetic setting, featuring curated music and a vibrant atmosphere that enhances the dining experience.
Why Choose The Nautilus?
- Innovative Cuisine: Experience a fusion of New England and global flavors, crafted with creativity and precision.
- Shared Dining Experience: The menu is designed for sharing, encouraging a communal and interactive meal.
- Expertly Curated Beverages: Enjoy a diverse selection of wines, sakes, and cocktails that perfectly complement the menu.
Getting There
Located at 12 Cambridge Street, The Nautilus is just steps off Main Street in downtown Nantucket, making it easily accessible by foot, bike, or car. Street parking is available but can be limited during peak hours.
Insider Tip:
Reservations are highly recommended due to the restaurant’s limited seating. Bookings can be made online up to seven days in advance, starting at midnight. For a unique experience, consider reserving the Captain’s Table, which accommodates larger parties and offers an extended dining time.
About The Club Car
Situated in the heart of downtown Nantucket, The Club Car is a historic restaurant and piano bar renowned for its vibrant atmosphere and live music. Housed in a vintage train car from the original Nantucket railroad, the establishment underwent a significant rebranding in 2017, introducing a modern interior with soft blue booths and abundant greenery. The Club Car offers a contemporary American menu with a focus on fresh, local seafood and seasonal ingredients.
Dining Highlights
- Signature Dishes:
- Steamed Mussels: Served with root vegetable chips.
- Crab Cake: Accompanied by beurre blanc.
- Grilled Octopus: Paired with zucchini fritters.
- Beverage Selection: The Club Car features an extensive selection of wines, specialty cocktails, and is particularly noted for its excellent piña coladas.
- Ambiance: The establishment combines historic charm with modern elegance, featuring live piano music that encourages guest participation, creating a lively and engaging dining experience.
Why Choose The Club Car?
- Historic Setting: Dine in a vintage train car, offering a unique and nostalgic atmosphere.
- Live Entertainment: Enjoy live piano performances, enhancing the dining experience with music and guest interaction.
- Central Location: Conveniently located on Main Street, making it easily accessible for both locals and visitors.
Getting There
The Club Car is located at 1 Main Street in downtown Nantucket, within walking distance of the ferry terminal and other central attractions. Street parking is available, though it may be limited during peak hours.
Insider Tip:
Reservations are recommended, especially during the busy season. The piano bar can become lively in the evenings; for a quieter dining experience, consider booking an earlier reservation.
About Pizzeria Gemelle
Pizzeria Gemelle, affectionately known as the “kid-sister” to Nantucket’s esteemed Ventuno Restaurant, specializes in authentic Neapolitan-style pizzas. The pizzeria prides itself on crafting each pie with house-made mozzarella and baking them in an Italian-imported oven, meticulously rebuilt brick by brick. This dedication to traditional methods ensures a genuine and flavorful pizza experience.
Dining Highlights
- Signature Pizzas:
- Margherita: A classic combination of San Marzano tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, and basil.
- The ‘Hog: Features local clams, bacon, spring onions, potato, and pecorino, offering a unique twist on traditional toppings.
- Annabella: Topped with house-made mozzarella, paper-thin guanciale, black truffles, and a runny egg, delivering a rich umami flavor.
- Beverage Selection: Pizzeria Gemelle offers a curated selection of wines and classic Italian cocktails, such as the Aperol Spritz, to complement their pizzas.
- Ambiance: The cozy and intimate setting reflects a blend of modern and traditional Italian aesthetics, creating a welcoming atmosphere for both casual diners and pizza enthusiasts.
Why Choose Pizzeria Gemelle?
- Authentic Neapolitan Pizzas: Experience pizzas made with traditional techniques and high-quality ingredients, including house-made mozzarella and an Italian-imported oven.
- Creative Toppings: Enjoy inventive combinations like the ‘Hog and Annabella, which showcase local ingredients and unique flavors.
- Convenient Location: Situated in downtown Nantucket, Pizzeria Gemelle is easily accessible for both residents and visitors.
Getting There
Located at 2 East Chestnut Street, Pizzeria Gemelle is within walking distance of many downtown attractions. Street parking is available, but can be limited during peak hours.
Insider Tip:
Pizzeria Gemelle does not take reservations and operates on a first-come, first-served basis. To avoid wait times, consider visiting during off-peak hours. For the latest updates and specials, follow their social media pages.
About 167 Raw
Established in 1978 by Bill Sandole, 167 Raw began as East Coast Provisions & Seafood Co., a fresh fish and meat wholesaler. In 1995, the business opened its retail store at 167 Hummock Pond Road, evolving into a beloved seafood market and food truck destination. Known for its commitment to fresh, high-quality seafood, 167 Raw has become a staple for both locals and visitors seeking authentic Nantucket flavors.
Dining Highlights
- Signature Dishes:
- Lobster Roll: Freshly prepared lobster meat served in a buttery roll.
- Fish Tacos: Made-to-order tacos featuring the catch of the day.
- Tuna Burger: A flavorful burger crafted from fresh tuna.
- Beverage Selection: The market offers a curated selection of wines and beers to complement their seafood offerings.
- Ambiance: Guests can enjoy their meals in the BYOB garden seating area, providing a relaxed and inviting atmosphere.
Why Choose 167 Raw?
- Fresh, Local Seafood: Sourced daily to ensure the highest quality.
- Casual Dining Experience: Ideal for a quick bite or a leisurely meal.
- Community Favorite: A go-to spot for authentic Nantucket seafood.
Getting There
Located at 167 Hummock Pond Road, 167 Raw is accessible by car or bike. Parking is available on-site, but spaces can be limited during peak hours.
Insider Tip:
Arrive early during peak seasons to avoid long lines, as 167 Raw is a popular destination for both locals and tourists.
About Sister Ship
Nestled within the Faraway Hotel in downtown Nantucket, Sister Ship is a restaurant, café, and relaxed cocktail club offering elevated cocktails alongside seafood-forward, Mediterranean-inspired dishes. The menu showcases New England seafood and local ingredients, providing a unique dining experience that blends coastal charm with Mediterranean flavors.
Far Away Hotels
Dining Highlights
- Signature Dishes:
- Island Creek Oysters: Freshly shucked oysters sourced from local waters.
- Rib-Eye for Two: A tender rib-eye steak, perfect for sharing. Boston Magazine
- Tuna Tartare: Fresh tuna prepared with a Mediterranean twist.
- Beverage Selection: Sister Ship offers a curated selection of elevated cocktails, wines, and beers, designed to complement their Mediterranean-inspired menu. Far Away Hotels
- Ambiance: The interior combines nautical chic with cozy décor, reminiscent of turn-of-the-century captain’s quarters meets underground speakeasy, creating an inviting atmosphere for both dining and socializing. Boston Magazine
Why Choose Sister Ship?
- Innovative Cuisine: Experience a fusion of Mediterranean flavors with New England seafood, crafted with local ingredients.
- Relaxed Cocktail Club: Enjoy a variety of elevated cocktails in a comfortable and stylish setting.
- Central Location: Situated in the heart of Nantucket, Sister Ship is easily accessible for both locals and visitors.
Getting There
Located at 29 Centre Street, Sister Ship is within walking distance of many downtown attractions. Street parking is available on Centre Street, Chestnut Street, Hussey Street, and Broad Street.
OpenTable
Insider Tip:
Reservations are recommended, especially during the busy summer season. For a unique experience, consider dining in the garden courtyard or enjoying the subterranean speakeasy vibes.
About Pi Pizzeria
Established in 2001, Pi Pizzeria has been serving authentic Neapolitan-style wood-fired pizzas and classic Italian-American dishes to the Nantucket community. The restaurant prides itself on traditional cooking methods, using fresh, high-quality ingredients to craft each dish. The cozy dining room and lively bar create a warm and inviting atmosphere for guests.
Dining Highlights
- Signature Dishes:
- Margherita Pizza: San Marzano tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, and basil.
- Great Italian Pizza: San Marzano tomato sauce, mozzarella, Esposito’s sausage, pepperoni, green pepper, and onion.
- Rustica Pizza: Arugula, stracchino cheese, pancetta, and garlic.
- Beverage Selection: Pi Pizzeria offers a selection of Italian wines, beers, and specialty cocktails to complement their menu.
- Ambiance: The restaurant features a cozy dining room filled with the aroma of wood-fired pizzas and simmering sauces, as well as a lively bar inspired by Italian traditions.
Why Choose Pi Pizzeria?
- Authentic Neapolitan Pizza: Experience traditional wood-fired pizzas made with fresh, high-quality ingredients.
- Classic Italian-American Cuisine: Enjoy a variety of dishes that reflect the rich culinary traditions of Italy.
- Inviting Atmosphere: The warm and lively setting is perfect for both casual dining and special occasions.
Getting There
Located at 11 West Creek Road, Pi Pizzeria is easily accessible by car or bike. Parking is available in both the front and back of the restaurant, with handicapped accessible spots and a ramp located behind the establishment.
Insider Tip:
Pi Pizzeria does not accept reservations and seats complete parties on a first-come, first-served basis. To avoid wait times, consider arriving early during peak dining hours.
About Millie’s
Located at the edge of Madaket Beach, Millie’s is a quintessential Nantucket dining destination known for its casual atmosphere, fresh coastal cuisine, and unbeatable sunset views. Named after Millie Jewett, a beloved Madaket resident, the restaurant reflects the laid-back charm of the island’s west end. Whether you’re enjoying tacos after a day at the beach or sipping on a signature cocktail while the sun sets, Millie’s captures the spirit of summer on Nantucket.
Dining Highlights
- Signature Dishes:
- Westender Tacos: Blackened mahi mahi in corn tortillas with pineapple mango salsa, guacamole, and lime sour cream.
- Hither Creek Tacos: Grilled striped bass with tomato and corn salsa, guacamole, and lime sour cream.
- Steps Beach Quesadilla: Lobster, roasted tomato, grilled zucchini, and Monterey jack cheese in a perfectly grilled tortilla.
- Beverage Selection:
Enjoy Millie’s renowned Madaket Mystery, a refreshing cocktail that pairs perfectly with the beachside setting, along with a curated selection of beers and wines.
- Ambiance:
The open-air dining area, complete with picnic tables and ocean breezes, makes Millie’s the perfect spot to soak in Madaket’s relaxed vibe.
Why Choose Millie’s?
- Unbeatable Location: Enjoy dining just steps from the beach, with stunning views of Nantucket’s famous sunsets.
- Fresh, Flavorful Cuisine: A menu featuring locally inspired tacos, quesadillas, and fresh seafood ensures a delicious dining experience.
- Laid-Back Atmosphere: Millie’s casual, beachy setting is ideal for families, friends, and couples alike.
Getting There
Situated at 326 Madaket Road, Millie’s is easily accessible by car, bike, or the NRTA Madaket shuttle. Parking is available, but arriving early is recommended during peak hours.
Insider Tip:
Arrive in the early evening to secure a table and enjoy a front-row seat to Madaket’s famous sunsets. Pair your meal with a Madaket Mystery and finish with a visit to Millie’s Market for a sweet treat.
